| No Editing Zone - Reports Fanfiction - Modern Dynasty - Garden of EVA Site/Contact Info | |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Japanese
name(s):
|
Dominion Tank Police |
|
English
name(s):
|
Dominion Tank Police |
|
Overall
description of edits/changes:
|
CPM's release edited together pairs of episodes and made changes to the endings used for ever pair of episodes.DETAILED REPORT |
|
Reviewed
by:
|
Giaourus Ericus |
|
Date
reviewed/updated:
|
Wednesday, April 14, 2004 6:05 PM |
|
North
American company releasing title:
|
CPM |
|
Japanese
version that North American version is based on:
|
As originally released on Japanese home video |
|
Detailed
description of opening and ending changes (contains opinions)
|
|
I wish to make it known that the beginning and ending credits of Central Park Media's DVD release of "Dominion Tank Police" are edited in the following two ways, both of which I find upsetting, the second of which much more so than the first.
In CPM's ending credits, the start and finish of the original ending credits (which only contain Buaku and the snow globe) are intact, but, as soon as the view zooms into the snow globe, the "frame" in which the original end credits exist shrinks, seeming to withdraw to the top-center of the screen, while the English credits begin scrolling by on a black background. Throughout the English credits, not only are The Puma Sisters minutely visible, but the original Japanese text of the credits are as well -- all so tiny as to be barely recognizable for what they are. After the view within the original credits draws away from The Puma Sisters and back out to Buaku, the original credit sequence fills the screen again. Watching CPM's edited ending is, to me, an exercise in frustration. For crying out loud, why effectively cut out those ending credits while leaving in both the other nude scenes AND that rather hilarious tanks-versus-plastic-landmines sequence? (And, no, I'm *NOT* suggesting cutting those too -- perish the thought!) At the very worst, leaving the ending credits intact could mean changing the age-rating from 13 Up to 16 Up. And this would be just fine, because, while both comical and *not* graphically extreme, "Dominion Tank Police" was never intended to be a children's show; in fact, aside from its wonderfully irreverent "Police Academy"-type hijinks, there are underlying concepts in it very like those in "Ghost in The Shell," freely speculating on a subject that practically no Western SF storytellers have ever had the nerve to so far, due to, I think, religious prejudice. (NOTE: For those unfamiliar with these titles, both "Dominion Tank Police" and "Ghost in The Shell" are based on manga by Masamune Shirow.) Like "Ghost," "Dominion" is, in addition to being a great anime, a profound work of speculative fiction, with an underlying concept that few children (and probably not all adults) would grasp. The intended audience for "Dominion" is at least in its mid-teens, rather "cute" character designs notwithstanding -- actually, they're cute because "Dominion" is a comedy, and it's typical for anime and manga characters in a comedy to be drawn cutely (i.e. "Ranma 1/2"), to help create a fun, whimsical mood; it doesn't necessarily mean that the anime or manga is intended for children (obviously). |
|
What
you can do to get the unedited version (import and domestic)
|
|
Write/contact:
|
|
This page last modified Wednesday, April 14, 2004 6:05 PM PST
All content (columns, reports, stories, original artwork, HTML source, etc...) on this web site is Copyright 1998-2007 by Jim Lazar and animeprime.com unless otherwise specified.
![]()